• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

El Jimador #5 - Authentic Mexican Flavors and Friendly Service in Porter, IN

El Jimador #5, located in Porter, Indiana, is a vibrant Mexican eatery known for its authentic flavors and warm atmosphere. The menu shines with standout dishes like carne asada tacos, chicken milanesa tortas, and flavorful carnitas, all made with fresh, quality ingredients. The housemade flour chips paired with corn tostadas and an edible guacamole bowl offer a creative and tasty experience. Friendly staff and attentive service elevate each visit, while the new bar and Taco Tuesday specials add lively charm. Whether for family meals or casual dining, El Jimador #5 delivers bold tastes and genuine hospitality worth discovering.

El Jimador #5 at a glance

  • Address 124 Lincoln St, Porter, IN 46304, United States
  • Phone +1 219-926-6518
  • Restaurant type Family restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

El Jimador #5: Reviews & Ratings

Rosie
5

The corn and housemade flour chips are really good. I like the combination. Really tasty tostada Swiss and fajitas. The edible bowl that holds guacamole and cheese was a visual and tasty bonus. It's a small business with tasty food and a hard-working staff. Horchata was delicious

Emerald Aztecpiper
5

Amazing menu! The food was absolutely delicious! And this review is from a Mexican American! My sister, who was visiting from Texas, said her flautas were to die for. Service was great!

Alejandro Lleras
5

We stopped here by accident, on our way to West Beach bc the Village Tavern next door won't allow kiddos. Oh my, what a struck of luck. I didn't take any pictures bc I was not initially planning on reviewing this restaurant and by the time I realize I should, there was Nothing left on anyone's plate. The chicken milanesa torta was great, the carnitas were amazing and the carne asada tacos were out of this world. Oh , sooo gooooooood. My wife, I and three kiddos devoured the food. Worth the detour. Trust me. It was hard for me to rate the atmosphere because we came at an odd time, between lunch and dinner, so we were the only ones in.

Karen Johansen
5

Their food is delicious and the waiters are so friendly, they are always right there if you need anything, they are very attentive. Would definitely recommend giving them a try. Prices are reasonable and they just built a brand new bar inside. Taco Tuesday special also!!

Barbara Hanna
5

It is under new management and the place looks great. They added a bar and the whole restaurant looks neat and clean. The tacos and guacamole were delicious. The new manager by the name of Alex went above and beyond to make sure everything was OK. We will defenetly come back and try other dishes.

Ann Marie Swen
5

This is literally the best Mexican food in this area. The meats are grilled perfectly. The rice and beans are fresh homemade and the service is great! We had Street tacos, an enchilada and chile rellenos. Best chile rellenos I ever had. I do wish they would turn part of the restaurant into a bar and I believe then they could compete with the other places nearby. I took some chips and salsa to go. Both fresh and homemade as well. Tuesday is $2 taco. Wow!

Location

  • El Jimador #5
    El Jimador #5
    124 Lincoln St, Porter, IN 46304, United States Hotline: +1 219-926-6518

El Jimador #5 stands out as a charming family restaurant nestled in the heart of Porter, Indiana. Known for its inviting atmosphere and a menu bursting with authentic Mexican flavors, it’s a place where both locals and travelers find comfort and delight. The highlight dishes, such as the crispy chimichanga and hearty house burritos, capture the essence of traditional Mexican cuisine with a modern twist, delivering bold flavors and satisfying portions.

The attention to detail here impresses—from the housemade flour chips paired with fresh corn tostadas to the inventive edible bowls that serve guacamole and cheese, enhancing both presentation and taste. The horchata, a refreshing and creamy beverage, provides a perfect balance to the spiced dishes, rounding out the meal with a touch of sweetness.

What truly elevates El Jimador #5 is its warm, attentive service and family-friendly vibe. The new bar addition complements the tasteful decor under new management, creating a welcoming setting for any occasion. Whether you crave carne asada tacos that melt with richness or chicken milanesa tortas packed with tender flavors, each dish tells a story of quality and passion.

From the rave reviews by Mexican American guests praising the authenticity to families stopping by unexpectedly and finding a hidden gem, El Jimador #5 consistently delivers joy through its food. It’s more than just a restaurant—it’s an experience where flavor and community blend seamlessly. For anyone seeking genuine Mexican comfort food, this spot is a must-visit.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards